Crazy ‘Agatha All Along’ Fan Theory Suggests Agatha Killed Her Own Son

‘Agatha All Along’ premiered with its first two episodes, and so far the first initial reactions are good when it comes to fans, as the show was tailored toward a specific type of audiences. Agatha is free to roam the world once again, but there is a twist, she is powerless and looking to reclaim that power.

Agatha will have to walk the Witches Road alongside a makeshift coven, and one seemingly powerless “Teen.” That “Teen” whose identity has been widely speculated might turn out to be a far greater part of Agatha’s life than we assume.

So far, “The Teen” is 95% confirmed to be Billy Kaplan aka Billy Maximoff aka Wiccan from the comics, but the other 5 % is one fan theory far darker than you can imagine. What if the Teen is actually a son that Agatha Harkness sacrificed?

Fan under the username ken posted on X an interesting theory that we’ve also written about, but our take had slightly more details.

What if Teen is actually Agatha’s son Nicholas Scratch, as she can be seen walking into a children’s bedroom in the first episode with the name appearing on a plaque? The bedroom has an occult and goth aesthetic, something that Teen also displayed in the first two episodes.

What if, in the past, Teen was actually Nicholas Scratch and Agatha sacrificed him at the Witches Road in order to get her hands on the Darkhold?

The twist also includes Aubrey Plaza’s Rio Vidal. The actress hinted even before the premiere that the two of them have a complicated past, hinting at some romantic undertones. It’s quite possible that Rio and Agatha were once lovers whose relationship went down the drain when Agatha sacrificed their son to acquire more power.

As I’ve said, Teen is as good as confirmed to be Billy at this point, but you never know with Agatha. What do you think? Let us know in the comments below!

Liked this article? Follow us on Facebook, Threads, and X to stay updated with the latest news.