New ‘Agatha All Along’ Trailer Drops, Sparking Fan Theories About a Mysterious New Character

Despite what some fans might say, Agatha All Along is doing quite well. While it may not be the MCU’s best series, it’s an entertaining show that expands the universe’s lore, introduces new characters, and gives us intriguing mysteries we can’t wait to see unfold.

Though several questions from earlier episodes remain unanswered, a new trailer has added even more intrigue by introducing a mysterious character—yet another puzzle for fans to solve. Naturally, the fandom is buzzing with excitement and speculation.

With that in mind, we took a dive into the fan reactions online. While the trailer didn’t reveal much, fans have already started making their guesses, and here’s everything you need to know about the theories surrounding this enigmatic character.

As always, let’s start by introducing you to the mysterious character at the center of all the buzz. Once you’ve had a look, we’ll break down everything you need to know about this latest development and the fan theories surrounding it:

As you can see, the image doesn’t offer many clues. This character could be anyone—from Wanda in a clever disguise to someone entirely new, like Mephisto, whose arrival has been teased so many times and eagerly anticipated by fans.

While the trailer gives no real hints about their identity, fans, armed with their deep knowledge of the lore, have already begun speculating. Here are some of the names and theories they’ve suggested:

We’ve sifted through the joke guesses, and as you can see, there are plenty of intriguing possibilities. We’re eager to find out who’s really lurking beneath the coat and hat this time around.

Got a theory of your own? Let us know in the comments below!

Liked this article? Follow us on Bluesky for the latest Marvel & DC news!